We don’t know why the universe exists. We don’t fully understand consciousness. We don’t know why the laws of physics have the values they do. These are three of the greatest mysteries in science and philosophy. But apparently, we can solve all three by introducing an even bigger mystery and calling it God.
That’s not an explanation. It’s a change of vocabulary.
Take the claim that the universe is finely tuned. Finely tuned compared to what? We have exactly one universe available for examination. We don’t know whether its physical constants could have been different, much less the probability of those alternatives. Saying the universe was designed for life gets things backward. Life evolved under the conditions the universe provided. Fish are well adapted to water, but that doesn’t mean oceans were created specifically for fish.
Consciousness presents another mystery. We don’t completely understand how the brain produces subjective experience, but we know quite a bit about the relationship. Brain injuries change personalities. Drugs alter perception. Anesthesia temporarily eliminates consciousness. Those are pretty substantial clues. Declaring consciousness beyond the reach of science because we haven’t solved it yet is rather like declaring disease supernatural before discovering bacteria.
Then there’s the argument that God must be good because a perfect being, by definition, must be good. But definitions don’t establish existence. I can define a perfectly intelligent purple elephant that knows everything about the universe. That doesn’t mean there’s one wandering around somewhere.
The discussion of biblical morality is even more troubling. The author acknowledges that scripture attributes enormous destruction and suffering to God but argues that God’s intentions make those actions compatible with perfect goodness. Imagine a human ruler destroying entire populations and then explaining that he did it out of love. Would we call that goodness or a war crime? Apparently, when the alleged perpetrator is God, the moral standards change.
But the most revealing part comes at the end. After examining atheism, theism, and agnosticism, the author embraces pantheism, the belief that God and the universe are the same thing.
Fine. But what have we learned?
We already have a word for the universe. Calling it God doesn’t explain where it came from, why its laws work, or how consciousness arises. It simply gives something we know exists a name associated with something whose existence hasn’t been demonstrated.
And atheism doesn’t require believing that science has all the answers. It doesn’t even require believing that every mystery will eventually be solved. It simply means not believing in gods. I’m perfectly comfortable admitting that there are things we don’t know. The difference is that I don’t see ignorance as evidence for a supernatural explanation.
History should make us cautious. Lightning, disease, earthquakes, and eclipses were once attributed to supernatural forces. We investigated them and discovered natural explanations. That doesn’t prove science will answer every question, but it certainly suggests that declaring a mystery permanently beyond science is a risky proposition.
I respect someone willing to reconsider their beliefs. But changing your mind isn’t proof that your new position is correct. And finding an explanation emotionally satisfying isn’t the same as demonstrating that it’s true.
The universe is roughly 13.8 billion years old. The atoms in our bodies were forged through cosmic processes reaching back billions of years. Here we are, on a small planet orbiting an ordinary star, with brains capable of studying the universe that produced them.
I find that extraordinary enough without assigning it a supernatural identity.
The author began with three mysteries and ended by calling the universe God. Yet all three mysteries remain.
**Giving the unknown a name isn’t the same thing as explaining it.**
The religions of the world don’t offer what I’m looking for.
I would like to belong to a religion whose motto is: **“Minimize suffering and maximize understanding,”** and that relies primarily on science to understand creation.
I would like an inclusive, contemporary, flexible, universal, and forward-looking religion.
A religion that is relevant today, here on this planet, but also on any other.
A religion that explains that pain and suffering are fundamentally survival mechanisms that have been reinforced through evolution since the origins of life, four billion years ago, rather than divine punishment.
A religion that preaches the importance of scientific knowledge instead of promoting ignorance through insistence on miracles, supernatural powers, and consubstantial transmutations.
A religion that adopts the Big Bang theory as its Genesis.
A religion in which empathy is the highest value.
A religion committed to minimizing the suffering of human beings, but also of all other living creatures.
A religion that begins preparing today for the first contact with other intelligences.
A religion whose highest clergy dedicate their lives to advancing and disseminating scientific knowledge.
A religion that doesn’t ask me to believe without seeing, but rather teaches me to be skeptical, to question my own foundational beliefs, and to remain forever flexible enough to change my mind in the light of new evidence.
A religion that, instead of focusing on a single person as both the beginning and the end of everything, celebrates all those who have contributed to the advancement of human understanding.
A religion that teaches that this is the only life we have, and that we should therefore make the most of it.
A religion that teaches that the intention of the Creator might be written into the chronology and structure of the universe itself.
From the Big Bang, 13.8 billion years ago, through cosmic inflation, the first light escaping the plasma, the formation of the first particles, the dark ages before the first stars, the formation of successive generations of suns, planets, and galaxies, and finally, life itself.
Perhaps somewhere in all of this, it might be possible to discover the deepest intention behind creation.
Soy huérfano de religión.
Las religiones del mundo no ofrecen lo que yo estoy buscando.
Me gustaría pertenecer a una religión que tuviera como lema: “Minimizar el sufrimiento y maximizar el entendimiento” y que usara preeminentemente a la ciencia para tratar de entender a la creación.
Me gustaría una religión incluyente, actualizada, flexible, universal y futurista.
Una religión que fuera relevante hoy aquí en este planeta pero también en cualquier otro.
Una religión que explicara que el dolor y el sufrimiento son elementalmente mecanismos de supervivencia que se han venido reforzando evolutivamente desde el origen de la vida hace 4 billones de años y no castigos divinos.
Una religión que predicara la importancia del conocimiento científico en vez de promover la ignorancia insistiendo sobre milagros, poderes sobrenaturales y transmutaciones consustanciales.
Una religión que adoptara la teoría del Big Bang como su Génesis.
Una religión donde la empatía fuera el valor principal.
Una religión que buscara minimizar el sufrimiento de los humanos pero también de todos los otros seres vivos.
Una religión que se preparara desde hoy para el primer contacto con otras inteligencias.
Una religión donde sus más altos clérigos dedicaran sus vidas en avanzar y diseminar el conocimiento científico.
Una religión que no me pidiera creer sin ver sino al contrario, que me enseñara a ser escéptico y a dudar de mis ideas fundacionales para siempre tener la flexibilidad de cambiar bajo la luz de nuevas evidencias.
Una religión que en vez de enfocarse en una sola persona como el principio y el fin, celebrara a todos los que han participado en el avance del entendimiento humano.
Una religión que predicara que esta, es la única vida que tenemos y por eso hay que aprovecharla al máximo.
Una religión que enseñara que en la cronología y en la estructura del universo pudiera estar plasmada la intención del creador.
Desde el Big Bang hace 13.8 billones de años, la hiperinflación, la primera luz que se escapa del plasma, la formación de las primeras partículas, las épocas oscuras antes de las primeras estrellas, la formación de soles, planetas y galaxias de sucesivas generaciones, la vida. En todo esto quizá sería posible descubrir la intención más profunda de la creación.
We don’t know why the universe exists. We don’t fully understand consciousness. We don’t know why the laws of physics have the values they do. These are three of the greatest mysteries in science and philosophy. But apparently, we can solve all three by introducing an even bigger mystery and calling it God.
That’s not an explanation. It’s a change of vocabulary.
Take the claim that the universe is finely tuned. Finely tuned compared to what? We have exactly one universe available for examination. We don’t know whether its physical constants could have been different, much less the probability of those alternatives. Saying the universe was designed for life gets things backward. Life evolved under the conditions the universe provided. Fish are well adapted to water, but that doesn’t mean oceans were created specifically for fish.
Consciousness presents another mystery. We don’t completely understand how the brain produces subjective experience, but we know quite a bit about the relationship. Brain injuries change personalities. Drugs alter perception. Anesthesia temporarily eliminates consciousness. Those are pretty substantial clues. Declaring consciousness beyond the reach of science because we haven’t solved it yet is rather like declaring disease supernatural before discovering bacteria.
Then there’s the argument that God must be good because a perfect being, by definition, must be good. But definitions don’t establish existence. I can define a perfectly intelligent purple elephant that knows everything about the universe. That doesn’t mean there’s one wandering around somewhere.
The discussion of biblical morality is even more troubling. The author acknowledges that scripture attributes enormous destruction and suffering to God but argues that God’s intentions make those actions compatible with perfect goodness. Imagine a human ruler destroying entire populations and then explaining that he did it out of love. Would we call that goodness or a war crime? Apparently, when the alleged perpetrator is God, the moral standards change.
But the most revealing part comes at the end. After examining atheism, theism, and agnosticism, the author embraces pantheism, the belief that God and the universe are the same thing.
Fine. But what have we learned?
We already have a word for the universe. Calling it God doesn’t explain where it came from, why its laws work, or how consciousness arises. It simply gives something we know exists a name associated with something whose existence hasn’t been demonstrated.
And atheism doesn’t require believing that science has all the answers. It doesn’t even require believing that every mystery will eventually be solved. It simply means not believing in gods. I’m perfectly comfortable admitting that there are things we don’t know. The difference is that I don’t see ignorance as evidence for a supernatural explanation.
History should make us cautious. Lightning, disease, earthquakes, and eclipses were once attributed to supernatural forces. We investigated them and discovered natural explanations. That doesn’t prove science will answer every question, but it certainly suggests that declaring a mystery permanently beyond science is a risky proposition.
I respect someone willing to reconsider their beliefs. But changing your mind isn’t proof that your new position is correct. And finding an explanation emotionally satisfying isn’t the same as demonstrating that it’s true.
The universe is roughly 13.8 billion years old. The atoms in our bodies were forged through cosmic processes reaching back billions of years. Here we are, on a small planet orbiting an ordinary star, with brains capable of studying the universe that produced them.
I find that extraordinary enough without assigning it a supernatural identity.
The author began with three mysteries and ended by calling the universe God. Yet all three mysteries remain.
**Giving the unknown a name isn’t the same thing as explaining it.**
Tim,
I want to be your friend. Nice one.
I Am an Orphan of Religion
The religions of the world don’t offer what I’m looking for.
I would like to belong to a religion whose motto is: **“Minimize suffering and maximize understanding,”** and that relies primarily on science to understand creation.
I would like an inclusive, contemporary, flexible, universal, and forward-looking religion.
A religion that is relevant today, here on this planet, but also on any other.
A religion that explains that pain and suffering are fundamentally survival mechanisms that have been reinforced through evolution since the origins of life, four billion years ago, rather than divine punishment.
A religion that preaches the importance of scientific knowledge instead of promoting ignorance through insistence on miracles, supernatural powers, and consubstantial transmutations.
A religion that adopts the Big Bang theory as its Genesis.
A religion in which empathy is the highest value.
A religion committed to minimizing the suffering of human beings, but also of all other living creatures.
A religion that begins preparing today for the first contact with other intelligences.
A religion whose highest clergy dedicate their lives to advancing and disseminating scientific knowledge.
A religion that doesn’t ask me to believe without seeing, but rather teaches me to be skeptical, to question my own foundational beliefs, and to remain forever flexible enough to change my mind in the light of new evidence.
A religion that, instead of focusing on a single person as both the beginning and the end of everything, celebrates all those who have contributed to the advancement of human understanding.
A religion that teaches that this is the only life we have, and that we should therefore make the most of it.
A religion that teaches that the intention of the Creator might be written into the chronology and structure of the universe itself.
From the Big Bang, 13.8 billion years ago, through cosmic inflation, the first light escaping the plasma, the formation of the first particles, the dark ages before the first stars, the formation of successive generations of suns, planets, and galaxies, and finally, life itself.
Perhaps somewhere in all of this, it might be possible to discover the deepest intention behind creation.
Soy huérfano de religión.
Las religiones del mundo no ofrecen lo que yo estoy buscando.
Me gustaría pertenecer a una religión que tuviera como lema: “Minimizar el sufrimiento y maximizar el entendimiento” y que usara preeminentemente a la ciencia para tratar de entender a la creación.
Me gustaría una religión incluyente, actualizada, flexible, universal y futurista.
Una religión que fuera relevante hoy aquí en este planeta pero también en cualquier otro.
Una religión que explicara que el dolor y el sufrimiento son elementalmente mecanismos de supervivencia que se han venido reforzando evolutivamente desde el origen de la vida hace 4 billones de años y no castigos divinos.
Una religión que predicara la importancia del conocimiento científico en vez de promover la ignorancia insistiendo sobre milagros, poderes sobrenaturales y transmutaciones consustanciales.
Una religión que adoptara la teoría del Big Bang como su Génesis.
Una religión donde la empatía fuera el valor principal.
Una religión que buscara minimizar el sufrimiento de los humanos pero también de todos los otros seres vivos.
Una religión que se preparara desde hoy para el primer contacto con otras inteligencias.
Una religión donde sus más altos clérigos dedicaran sus vidas en avanzar y diseminar el conocimiento científico.
Una religión que no me pidiera creer sin ver sino al contrario, que me enseñara a ser escéptico y a dudar de mis ideas fundacionales para siempre tener la flexibilidad de cambiar bajo la luz de nuevas evidencias.
Una religión que en vez de enfocarse en una sola persona como el principio y el fin, celebrara a todos los que han participado en el avance del entendimiento humano.
Una religión que predicara que esta, es la única vida que tenemos y por eso hay que aprovecharla al máximo.
Una religión que enseñara que en la cronología y en la estructura del universo pudiera estar plasmada la intención del creador.
Desde el Big Bang hace 13.8 billones de años, la hiperinflación, la primera luz que se escapa del plasma, la formación de las primeras partículas, las épocas oscuras antes de las primeras estrellas, la formación de soles, planetas y galaxias de sucesivas generaciones, la vida. En todo esto quizá sería posible descubrir la intención más profunda de la creación.
Rich,
The above comment by Tim deserves to be its own piece.